Obama, Berlin and the world

So what did we expect from Barack Obama’s foreign policy speech in Berlin?  Since Barack Obama is not even the official democratic candidate yet, and obviously not the US President, I think expectations were hugely exaggerated. Apart from that, the following list of expectations sums it up (at least for me):

  1. Great visions for the future of everything: yes.   – Policy details: no, not really.
  2. Great rhetoric: yes.  – Great visuals for his campaign: yes, definitely.
  3. Bush-bashing: no. – And a “Berlin surprise”: Oh yes please.

And what did we get? (You can read the transcript of the speech here)

1. What about “visions”: well, sort of. Barack Obama spoke about many global problems and a lot of shared responsibilities and the need for cooperation. Not more, not less. Of course freedom played a big role (George W. Bush would have said the same!). Also the importance of immigration is something Europe needs to learn! Interesting maybe the issue of nuclear disarmament. I haven’t heard any politician to call for that in the last decade or so. Of course he did not go into any detail (it is election campaign time! not a good time for details). However, the “big visionary moment” of the speech was missing. But considering what could have gone wrong with such a speech, I guess it was OK. But of course symbolism prevails over content in every election campaign…

2. What about “great rhetoric”: First of all, I think the rather short speech was well constructed. The second part was better than the beginning. But I also found that the family background did not really work (maybe he should have started with something else and talked about it later? ). I liked the idea of a “world citizen” (what do you expect with that blog name…?). The delivery was very professional but, again, the big moment was missing. BUT the visuals for the campaign were great (and eventually that matters at the moment): They can suggest that he is respected and hugely popular in Europe (the crowd of 200 000 was impressive, right? ) which might give him some foreign policy credibility in the US. But that depends on the spin of the campaign…

3) Obviously no Bush-bashing abroad which is unthinkable in the diplomatic world. So what about the “Berlin surprise”: Nothing really. Basically he used Ernst Reuter and the Berlin airlift for his speech trying to put it in context with globalisation and global challenges. Not a bad idea. But then again, since expectations were huge I doubt that he could have delivered a real “surprise”. Maybe next time…

Anything else?

Well, from a European perspective we can take note that he knows about the EU and he generally thinks highly of global institutions and international cooperation, which is good to know. But I think the really remarkable thing is the pure existence of this event, a kind of “globalisation of US election campaigning”. I think we will see similar events in the future! As somebody on German TV said “It seems that he is the candidate for the world presidency”.

Update: Here is the video of the speech:

About these ads

5 responses to “Obama, Berlin and the world

  1. And a crowd of cheering Germans would never make a bad choice.

    In his speach he said “No walls can stand between people”…. Wow! That would have been really meaningful back in the 80′s. Or wait, maybe he meant the border fence down Mexico way…

    You forgot to mention that adoring crowd was there to see a free concert.
    Obama gave his speach between sets.

    Have some more kool aid.

  2. I did not mention the concerts because I think they were not relevant at all. And not unusual either. Moreover, DJ Mantu, Patrice and Reamonn are not the kind of music acts that would attracht 200.000 people.

    And about “no walls can stand between people”: Indeed not an innovative and new statement but always relevant (also in a human rights sense) and an obvious choice for Berlin!

  3. marleylegacy

    Yes WE ARE citizens of the world, WE ARE one, please listen to the lyrics of this song WE ARE that I found on Youtube. his name is Francis Jocky, he is so right, we’re all of one, one of all… Just beautiful.

  4. Pingback: Reactions to Obama’s Berlin speech « The 8th Circle

  5. Pingback: Barack Obama’s European Vacation | Nosemonkey’s EUtopia